In Josh Safdie’s Marty Supreme, there’s a scene where Marty Mauser (Timothée Chalamet) points out how hard it is to see a white ping-pong ball on a white surface, suggesting his orange ball, which stands out regardless of where it is. In Marty Supreme, cinematographer Darius Khondji shoots Chalamet’s Marty like this orange ball you can’t take your eyes off, a brightness in a darker world he’s trying to burst out of. Khondji’s work makes us feel the griminess of ‘50s New York City, as well as the elegance of those in a better position than Marty that he strives for. From the darkly-lit ping-pong tournaments that present these matches like a massive sporting event, to the harsh lighting of the hospital at the film’s end, Khondji always finds just the right feel for what this film needs.
Khondji has been nominated in this category three times, previously for Evita in 1997 and Bardo: False Chronicle of a Handful of Truths in 2023, and it’s honestly shocking he hasn’t been nominated more, considering his work. Of all the nominees this year, Khondji might’ve had the most impressive 2025, as he also shot both Ari Aster’s Eddington and Bong Joon-ho’s Mickey 17. Beyond that, it’s even more surprising Khondji hasn’t been nominated more often, as his work is truly staggering. He first worked with Safdie on Uncut Gems, and he was the cinematographer for such films as Se7en, Okja, Panic Room, Midnight in Paris, and Michael Haneke’s 2007 remake of Funny Games. Based simply on their filmography so far, Khondji is arguably the cinematographer on this list who deserves this award the most, given his history, but it’s still probably not going to be his year, considering the strength of the other nominees.